What goes on a shortlist

A shortlist here is a handful of titles we would hand a friend without a warning label. We watched the free episodes of every title in our selection, then kept four on each platform. The reason for each one is a fact you can check beside it: the length, the free viewing, the episode count, or the placing the platform itself gives the title.

Those placings are the platforms' own signals and sit beside each title with their source. They are not our grades, and we choose the four without looking for the platform's highest. Our four Candy AI titles sit between No. 67 of 170 in the Candy AI catalog order and No. 137 of 170 in the Candy AI catalog order, which is a reminder of how little that order tells you about whether a story is good.

Candy AI: a thief tale, then three quick ones

Our pick here is Trespasser of the Sunken Court, a fantasy of five episodes and about 6 minutes in which a thief gets caught in an elven realm and kept instead of ended. It sits at No. 137 of 170 in the Candy AI catalog order, and it is the one we'd open first anyway, because the stakes are clear within the first minute.

The other three are short and fast to judge. The Open House (No. 67 of 170 in the Candy AI catalog order) is an affair told in about 5 minutes. The Anniversary Massage (No. 69 of 170 in the Candy AI catalog order) has six episodes and about 7 minutes. My First Night Shift (No. 78 of 170 in the Candy AI catalog order) is a romance of five episodes and about 5 minutes. Our take on the group: it suits someone who wants a whole premise before a coffee goes cold.

Dreamy Shorts: one suspense and three that run longer

Our pick is Who Keeps Texting My Wife?, the one suspense on the platform among the titles we cover, with six episodes and about 6 minutes. Dreamy Shorts shows it at No. 4 in the Trending row on Dreamy Shorts.

Full English (No. 1 in the Top 10 row on Dreamy Shorts) is an affair set in a guesthouse. Connecting Door (No. 3 in the Top 10 row on Dreamy Shorts) has 12 episodes, twice what most of its neighbors have. Elapsed (No. 7 in the Trending row on Dreamy Shorts) is a fantasy of about 8 minutes with about 3 minutes free. Our take: these suit a viewer who is ready for one Premium plan and a story that takes a little longer to turn.

Secrets: three comedies and a fantasy

Our pick is Her Number One Fan, a comedy of 11 minutes with 2 minutes 58 seconds free. Secrets lists it No. 45 of 66 published series by Secrets' popularity score, and we kept it first because its premise is the easiest to judge in a single sentence.

Probed (No. 8 of 66 published series by Secrets' popularity score) is another comedy, with 4 minutes free. Down Below (No. 13 of 66 published series by Secrets' popularity score) is the fantasy, at 8 minutes. My Dirty Accountant (No. 14 of 66 published series by Secrets' popularity score) is a comedy of 11 minutes. Our take: this is the group for someone who wants to laugh and wants exact times.

Why there is no order across platforms

Each platform measures its titles in its own way: a catalog order on Candy AI, home-page rows on Dreamy Shorts, a popularity score on Secrets. None of the three tells us how it sets them, so we never put one beside another and never say that a title on one platform beats a title on another.

Where to start tonight depends on what you want. For a free try with plenty of minutes, open a free first try. For a story you can finish quickly, see a short evening. For more episodes, a longer story is the page. If you have no preference at all, we'd start with Trespasser of the Sunken Court, and the method behind every list is on how we pick.